文章摘要
董燕萍,雷水英,王攀智,钱寿初.医学论文质量评价的若干问题.编辑学报,2009,21(3):212-214
医学论文质量评价的若干问题
Several problems in assessing quality of biomedical papers
投稿时间:2008-12-05  修订日期:2008-12-05
DOI:
中文关键词: 医学论文  质量评价  引文分析  影响因子  公开存取
英文关键词: medical paper  quality assessment  citation analysis  impact factor  open access
基金项目:
作者单位
董燕萍 国际肝胆胰疾病杂志英文版编辑部,310003,杭州: 
雷水英 国际肝胆胰疾病杂志英文版编辑部,310003,杭州: 
王攀智 国际肝胆胰疾病杂志英文版编辑部,310003,杭州: 
钱寿初 中华医学杂志英文版编辑部,100710,北京 
摘要点击次数: 915
全文下载次数: 922
中文摘要:
      医学论文质量评价、信息交换的传统模式正在发生变化。审稿方法有明显缺陷而改革乏力。引文分析和影响因子的使用存在争议,且偏离了正确的使用轨道。开放存取出版模式与传统审稿方法相结合或许能成为医学论文评价的一种途径,做到真正意义上的“公开,公平,公正”。
英文摘要:
      The conventional models of quality assessment of biomedical papers and information exchange have greatly changed in the last few years. Peer review system has its weakness in medical journal publishing but has not changed much worldwide. The use of citation analysis and impact factor in assessment of research papers is out the correct track. Open access in combination with traditional peer review system seems to be feasible in evaluating biomedical research papers, and in some sense it is "open, fair and justice".
查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭