文章摘要
马英.国外医学期刊的审稿标准.编辑学报,2009,21(3):276-278
国外医学期刊的审稿标准
Reviewer criteria for peer review in overseas medical periodicals
投稿时间:2008-09-25  修订日期:2008-09-25
DOI:
中文关键词: 同行评议  审稿标准  国外医学期刊
英文关键词: peer review  reviewer criteria  overseas medical periodical
基金项目:
作者单位
马英 中华骨科杂志编辑部,300211,天津 
摘要点击次数: 925
全文下载次数: 452
中文摘要:
      以美国版骨与关节外科为例,探讨国外医学期刊的审稿标准。它们基于同行评议制度的审稿标准具有2个突出特点:一是总体评价与分项把关相结合;二是内容评议与方法学评议并重。科学、翔实的审稿标准有利于规范审稿人的审稿行为,帮助编辑评判稿件的学术价值和报告水平,为作者修改稿件提供指导和建议。
英文摘要:
      Basing on the Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery Am., the reviewer guidelines of peer review in overseas medical periodicals are discussed. There are two most important characters. One is a principle for content review including overall comments and specific comments. The other one is a two-tier review system consisting of content review and methodological review. A well-organized, detailed reviewer guideline will provide criteria for evaluating manuscripts, instructions for modifying manuscripts.
查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭