文章摘要
李军纪,阮爱萍,王沁萍.多媒介融合出版条件下学术期刊同行评审制度的发展.编辑学报,2016,28(6):539-543
多媒介融合出版条件下学术期刊同行评审制度的发展
Development of peer review system of academic journals under the condition of multi-media publishing technique
投稿时间:2015-03-30  修订日期:2015-03-30
DOI:
中文关键词: 学术期刊  同行评审  多媒介融合出版
英文关键词: academic journal  peer review  multi-media publishing technique
基金项目:山西医科大学科技创新基金资助项目
作者单位
李军纪 《山西医科大学学报》编辑部,030001,太原 
阮爱萍 《山西医科大学学报》编辑部,030001,太原 
王沁萍 《山西医科大学学报》编辑部,030001,太原 
摘要点击次数: 1203
全文下载次数: 965
中文摘要:
      为了分析多媒介融合出版技术对学术期刊同行评审制度的影响,为我国实施同行评审制度改革提供不同的选择途径,文章分析了传统学术期刊同行评审制度实施过程中遭遇的挑战和存在的问题,包括来自投稿数量的增加,来自非学术因素的干扰和传统评审制度自身的弊端。总结国内外重要期刊进行同行评审制度创新的模式,主要有开放同行评审、出版后同行评审和标准化同行评审等形式。认为:办刊人要充分利用多媒介融合出版技术下同行评审制度开放性、互动性、高效性的特点,创新中国学术期刊的同行评审制度,加强对同行评审制度的文化研究,强化同行评审的质量控制,以提高我国学术期刊的质量。
英文摘要:
      In order to explore the impact of multi-media publishing technique on the peer review system of academic journal, the challenges and problems in practicing traditional peer review process for academic journals are investigated, which included the increase of academic paper volume, nonacademic factors’ influence, and the shortcomings of traditional peer review system. Then the innovation modes of peer review system of some leading journals in western countries are discussed, which include open peer review system, post-publishing peer review system, and standard peer review system. At last, some suggestions are provided to improve the quality of Chinese academic journals. To integrate multimedia publishing technique into conventional paper based peer review system, we should take advantage of multi-media publishing’s openness, its interactivity and its effectiveness to innovate Chinese journals’ peer review system.
查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭