| 王旻玥,张洋,陈勇,郭伟.“工科理科化”倾向下的科技期刊工程特色栏目建设和差异化同行评议方法探析.编辑学报,2023,(6):652-655 |
| “工科理科化”倾向下的科技期刊工程特色栏目建设和差异化同行评议方法探析 |
| Construction of sci-tech journal columns with engineering characteristics and research of differentiated peer review methods under the trend of scientification of engineering |
| |
| DOI：10.16811/j.cnki.1001-4314.2023.06.012 |
| 中文关键词: 工科理科化 《工程前沿》栏目 差异化同行评议 评价指标 |
| 英文关键词: scientification of engineering the column called frontiers of engineering differentiated peer review evaluationindex |
| 基金项目:*2023年度全国学会期刊出版能力提升计划——高水平中文期刊培育项目(2023KJQK11)；湖北省科技期刊楚天卓越行动计划“楚天领军期刊”资助项目(鄂科协办[2022]81号)；中国高校科技期刊研究会青年基金项目(CUJS-QN-2023-017) |
|
| 摘要点击次数: 29 |
| 全文下载次数: 169 |
| 中文摘要: |
| 为响应扭转“工科理科化”倾向的呼吁,《中国机械工程》展开了《工程前沿》栏目建设。本文分析了该栏目的稿件来源、发文表现和同行评议特征；总结了现有评价体系下打造工程特色栏目面临的挑战,如部分工程实践单位不重视论文发表、现有同行评议规则中工程应用型论文难获认可、栏目内容与读者需求仍有差距；提出了适用于工程应用型论文的差异化同行评议方法,从突出工程特色的评价指标选择、具有工程背景的评审专家库建设和编委参与栏目质量把关等方面给出了建议。 |
| 英文摘要: |
| In response to the call of reversing the trend of scientification of engineering, the column called frontiers of engineering of China Mechanical Engineering was launched here in.Based on the analyses of the source of manuscripts, publication performance and peer review characteristics of the column, challenges of strengthening engineering feature are summarized under the existing evaluation system, e.g.some engineering enterprises pay little attention to paper publication, engineering application papers are hard to receive recognition under the existing peer review rules, and the column content still can’t meet readers’ needs. A differentiated peer review method suitable for engineering application papers is put forward. Suggestions are proposed from the aspects of evaluation indexes highlighting engineering characteristics, review expert database with engineering background, and column quality control by editorial board. |
|
查看全文
查看/发表评论 下载PDF阅读器 |
| 关闭 |
|
|
|
