文章摘要
程红,李莉.学术期刊正交试验类稿件的审读方法.编辑学报,2012,24(5):450-452
学术期刊正交试验类稿件的审读方法
Reviewing methods for manuscripts about orthogonal tests in academic journals
投稿时间:2012-03-17  修订日期:2012-03-17
DOI:
中文关键词: 科技论文  正交试验  稿件审读
英文关键词: sci-tech paper  orthogonal test  review  academic quality
基金项目:
作者单位
程红 《东北林业大学学报》编辑部,150040,哈尔滨 
李莉 《广西植物》编辑部,541006,广西桂林 
摘要点击次数: 260
全文下载次数: 1166
中文摘要:
      以农林类A+和A类期刊题名或
英文摘要:
      Academic papers focusing on orthogonal tests (experiments) in agriculture and forestry are surveyed and analyzed statistically based on the orthogonal test (experiment) theory. The results show that the papers with wrong expression of orthogonal marks account for 20.29% of the total surveyed papers, wrong k values for 28.77%, wrong R values for 27.97%, wrong arrangements in a primary order for 17.01%, and wrong combinations for 26.80%. The variance analysis among factors is confirmed to be insignificant in 31.86% papers. All these mistakes finally result in 63.13% papers with wrong conclusions or failed test design, suggesting that the academic quality of papers regarding orthogonal tests is worrying. Some proofreading methods for recognizing and revising these mistakes are provided from the editor's perspective. Meanwhile, journal publishing departments should strengthen the preliminary review of such kind of papers.
查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭