文章摘要
史冠中,姚戈,王淑华.地学论文审稿中的利益冲突及其规避.编辑学报,2014,26(5):447-448
地学论文审稿中的利益冲突及其规避
Interest conflicts and avoidance in manuscript review of geoscience papers
投稿时间:2013-10-19  修订日期:2013-10-19
DOI:
中文关键词: 地学论文  审稿  利益冲突  规避机制
英文关键词: geosciences, manuscript review, conflict, avoidance mechanism
基金项目:中央高校基本科研业务专项资金资助(2014289029)
作者单位
史冠中 中国地质大学武汉《地球科学》编辑部,430074,武汉 
姚戈 中国地质大学武汉《地球科学》编辑部,430074,武汉 
王淑华 中国地质大学武汉《地球科学》编辑部,430074,武汉 
摘要点击次数: 817
全文下载次数: 627
中文摘要:
      地学论文与其他学科相比,具有研究地域、资助方和审稿周期差异等特点。这导致审稿过程中在论文作者、审稿人及期刊编辑之间产生利益冲突。文章从观点差异、研究地域、资助方和审稿周期角度分别阐述利益冲突的表现形式。认为建立相应的审核机制和屏蔽机制,同时利用现在网络和软件等方式,对稿件审核进行追踪,从而最大限度地规避利益冲突。
英文摘要:
      ∥ Manuscript review is the essential process for selecting high-quality research articles. Geosciences, in contrast to other academic disciplines, have a few special characteristics in research areas, funders, review period etc. This easily leads to diverse conflicts of interest among authors, reviewers and journal staff. This study presents the content of conflicts, including difference in point of view, similarity in research region, funder intervention and delay of review. Proposals of taking advantage of current networks and software and establishing appropriate review system are put forward to maximally avoid conflicts.
查看全文   查看/发表评论  下载PDF阅读器
关闭